Shelter Island, NY
Is Shelter Island Heights - Shelter Island, NY a Safe Place to Live? Housing, Crime & Buyer Guide
Explore safety, home prices, commute patterns, and neighborhood insights in Shelter Island, New York - so you can decide with confidence before buying or renting.
Most buyers only see the home. Smart buyers check the neighborhood first.
Crime Summary:
Crime Overview (last 12 months)
Severe127
Medium133
Low143
Other315
1 Registered Offenders Nearby
Rape1
Child involved0
Assault0
Other0
Crime Details:
Recent reported incidents in the past 12 months (newest first). Up to 10 records.
| Crime date | Crime description | Address | Crime category |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a lift assist is requested near Park Street, across from Harbor Boulevard. The caller states two people may be needed to help. | Park St, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, ambulance and EMS are dispatched in East Hampton for an elderly woman with a possible stroke near Ocean Boulevard by Queens Lane. | Ocean Blvd, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were requested to a location near Newtown Lane by a traffic control officer for a reported incident involving a male and a female in one vehicle outside a nearby church. | Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Disturbance |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, emergency medical services responded for an elderly female with a possible transient ischemic attack near Ocean Boulevard and Queens Lane in East Hampton. | Ocean Blvd, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a welfare check is underway near Pantigo Road for a subject possibly sleeping in the back of a white box truck. | Pantigo Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a well-being check was requested near Amys Court involving a gray BMW from (number withheld) after a person reportedly pushed a panic button. | Amys Ct, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were sent to an ordinance complaint about possible burning of yard debris near Jackson Street between Three Mile Harbor and Springs Fireplace Road, after a next-door neighbor reported the issue involving nearby properties on that street. | Jackson St, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Fire |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were sent to the area near Main Street and The Circle to investigate a reported cell phone hang-up call. | Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Suspicious Activity |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, emergency crews responded to reports of low or partially downed wires near a trailer park off Oakview Highway, apparently hanging between utility poles or near homes and creating a roadway hazard. Utility workers were being contacted to check and secure the lines. | Oakview Hwy, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Road Closure |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, multiple EMS units responded to a second alarm for a sick male at trailer (number withheld) in East Hampton Trailer Park near Oakview Highway. | Oakview Hwy, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Medical Emergency |
For all crime details - View Safety Report
College Degree Rate
56.7%
Per Capita Income
$63,652
Vacancy Rate
57.8%
Nearby neighborhoods
Neighborhood Overview
Shelter Island Heights is a small, coastal town in New York with a population of 3,316. It is ethnically diverse and highly educated, with over half the adults holding college degrees.
The neighborhood has a high vacancy rate of 57.8%, typical of resort areas with seasonal occupancy. It offers a mix of housing and is known for a strong work-from-home culture.
CoastalDiverseEducatedHigh Work-From-Home
Quick Facts
| Work From Home Rate | 33.9% |
|---|
Housing market and real estate character
Shelter Island Heights has a high vacancy rate reflecting seasonal use. The housing stock includes a variety of types in a coastal setting.
| Owner Occupied Rate |
|---|
What buyers will notice right away
High vacancy rate indicates many homes are seasonally occupied, common in resort areas.
Families & Lifestyle
The neighborhood is attractive to retirees, urban sophisticates, families, and highly educated executives.
Retiree Friendly — More retiree-friendly than 97.0% of New York neighborhoods due to safety, quiet, and housing diversity.
Creative & Professional Community — High concentration of artists and professionals supports a vibrant cultural character.
| Same-Sex Couples | Higher than 98.4% of U.S. neighborhoods |
|---|---|
| Child Poverty Rate | 0.0% |
Demographics
| College Degree Rate | 56.7% |
|---|---|
| Per Capita Income | $63,652 |
| Work From Home Rate | 33.9% |
| Income Rank | Top 12.4% in U.S. |
| Foreign Born | 15.0% |
| Top Languages | ["English (81.3%)","Spanish (15.8%)","Italian"] |
| Top Ancestries | ["Irish (25.3%)","Mexican (14.0%)","Italian (12.7%)","German (9.1%)","Asian (5.3%)"] |
Commute
Many residents enjoy short commutes or work from home. Ferry commuting is notably high.
Shelter Island Heights offers unique ferry commuting and a high rate of telecommuting, enhancing lifestyle flexibility.
Ferry Commute — 7.7% of commuters use ferry, a rare and convenient option.
High Telecommuting — 33.9% work from home, supporting a knowledge-based workforce.
| Work From Home Rate | 33.9% |
|---|---|
| Ferry Commute Rate | 7.7% |
| Drive Alone Rate | 45.5% |
| Carpool Rate | 7.8% |
Homes for sale near 11930
For-sale listings in this zip code. Open a property in HoodScore to run a safety report.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Shelter Island Heights a coastal neighborhood?
Yes, it is located on the ocean, a bay, or inlet with a nautical character.
What is the vacancy rate?
The vacancy rate is 57.8%, reflecting seasonal occupancy common in resort areas.
What languages are spoken?
English is most common, with Spanish and Italian also spoken.