Montauk Station, NY

Is Montauk, NY (Montauk Station) a Safe Place to Live? Housing, Crime & Buyer Guide

Explore safety, home prices, commute patterns, and neighborhood insights in Montauk, NY - so you can decide with confidence before buying or renting.

Most buyers only see the home. Smart buyers check the neighborhood first.

View Safety Report See All Properties For Sale

Hoodscore

Crime Summary:

Crime Overview (last 12 months)

Severe127

Medium133

Low143

Other315

1 Registered Offenders Nearby

Rape1

Child involved0

Assault0

Other0

Crime Details:

Recent reported incidents in the past 12 months (newest first). Up to 10 records.

Crime date	Crime description	Address	Crime category
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, a lift assist is requested near Park Street, across from Harbor Boulevard. The caller states two people may be needed to help.	Park St, East Hampton, NY 11937	Medical Emergency
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, ambulance and EMS are dispatched in East Hampton for an elderly woman with a possible stroke near Ocean Boulevard by Queens Lane.	Ocean Blvd, East Hampton, NY 11937	Medical Emergency
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were requested to a location near Newtown Lane by a traffic control officer for a reported incident involving a male and a female in one vehicle outside a nearby church.	Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937	Disturbance
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, emergency medical services responded for an elderly female with a possible transient ischemic attack near Ocean Boulevard and Queens Lane in East Hampton.	Ocean Blvd, East Hampton, NY 11937	Medical Emergency
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, a welfare check is underway near Pantigo Road for a subject possibly sleeping in the back of a white box truck.	Pantigo Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937	Medical Emergency
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, a well-being check was requested near Amys Court involving a gray BMW from (number withheld) after a person reportedly pushed a panic button.	Amys Ct, East Hampton, NY 11937	Medical Emergency
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were sent to an ordinance complaint about possible burning of yard debris near Jackson Street between Three Mile Harbor and Springs Fireplace Road, after a next-door neighbor reported the issue involving nearby properties on that street.	Jackson St, East Hampton, NY 11937	Fire
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were sent to the area near Main Street and The Circle to investigate a reported cell phone hang-up call.	Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937	Suspicious Activity
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, emergency crews responded to reports of low or partially downed wires near a trailer park off Oakview Highway, apparently hanging between utility poles or near homes and creating a roadway hazard. Utility workers were being contacted to check and secure the lines.	Oakview Hwy, East Hampton, NY 11937	Road Closure
Jul 16, 2026	As discussed during the dispatch call, multiple EMS units responded to a second alarm for a sick male at trailer (number withheld) in East Hampton Trailer Park near Oakview Highway.	Oakview Hwy, East Hampton, NY 11937	Medical Emergency

For all crime details - View Safety Report

Median Home Price

$1,549,177

Average Rent

$4,295

Vacancy Rate

56.3%

Nearby neighborhoods

Overview

Montauk Station is a rural coastal neighborhood in Montauk, New York, with a median home price of $1,549,177, ranking above most neighborhoods in the state and nation.

The area has a high vacancy rate of 56.3%, often due to seasonal occupancy, and features mostly medium to large single-family homes and townhomes built mainly between 1970 and 1999.

CoastalRuralHigh VacancyOwner Occupied

Quick Facts

Seasonal Occupancy	52.0%

Housing market and real estate character

Montauk Station's housing consists mainly of medium to large single-family homes and townhomes, with a high vacancy rate typical of vacation areas.

Owner Occupied Rate

What buyers will notice right away

High vacancy and seasonal occupancy indicate many homes are vacation properties.

Most homes built between 1970 and 1999, with some from 1940 to 1969.

Families & Lifestyle

Montauk Station is peaceful and quiet, attracting retirees and educated seniors, with a diverse housing stock.

Quiet and safe environment appeals to retirees.

Diverse housing options support various lifestyles.

Retiree Friendly — Highly rated for retirees due to safety and quietness.

Retiree Friendliness	More retiree-friendly than 99.1% of NY neighborhoods

Demographics

Per Capita Income
Executive, Management, and Professional Occupations	42.3%
Foreign Born Residents	10.7%
Top Ancestries	["Irish","Italian","German","Polish","English"]
Top Languages	["English","Spanish","Greek"]

Commute

Most residents drive alone to work, with many enjoying short commutes under 15 minutes.

Commute data helps understand daily life and transportation needs in Montauk Station.

Short Commutes — Majority have commutes under 15 minutes.

Car Dependent — Most residents drive alone to work.

Drive Alone Rate	71.5%
Commute Under 15 Minutes	57.1%

Homes for sale near 11930

For-sale listings in this zip code. Open a property in HoodScore to run a safety report.

$399,999

2 bd | 2 ba | 1,181 sqft

11930 N Bayshore Dr APT 609

Miami, FL, 33181