Water Mill, NY
Is Water Mill, NY a Safe Place to Live? Housing, Crime & Buyer Guide
Explore safety, home prices, commute patterns, and neighborhood insights in Water Mill, New York - so you can decide with confidence before buying or renting.
Most buyers only see the home. Smart buyers check the neighborhood first.
Crime Summary:
Crime Overview (last 12 months)
Severe181
Medium182
Low234
Other403
1 Registered Offenders Nearby
Rape0
Child involved0
Assault0
Other1
Crime Details:
Recent reported incidents in the past 12 months (newest first). Up to 10 records.
| Crime date | Crime description | Address | Crime category |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers responded to a report of possible reckless or erratic driving involving a silver BMW near the intersection of Scuttle Hole Road and Head of Pond Road. The reported license plate information appeared to be inaccurate or related to a different vehicle. | Scuttle Hole Rd & Head of Pond Rd, Water Mill, NY 11976 | Traffic |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers are responding to a reported non‑injury traffic crash where a parked gray Mitsubishi was struck near Long Island Avenue, with indications it may be a hit‑and‑run style property‑damage incident. | Long Island Ave, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 | Traffic |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, dispatchers discuss a possible welfare concern involving a female reportedly locked in a bathroom at an apartment on Division Street in Sag Harbor. The location is confirmed as an upper-floor apartment in a multi-unit building. | Division St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 | Suspicious Activity |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, dispatchers report a possible 911 hang-up call from a location near Montauk Boulevard and Route 114 in East Hampton. | Montauk Blvd, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Suspicious Activity |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, emergency medical services responded to a female with a broken rib near Main Street in Sag Harbor, with police on scene near Chase Bank. | Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were sent to a reported panic alarm at a location near Crossways and the intersections with Lee and Georgia streets. | The Crossways, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Suspicious Activity |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, east Hampton Fire Department responded to an automatic fire alarm at a residence on Bull Path. The alarm was apparently set off by cooking, and there was no smoke or fire. All fire units returned to service. | Bull Path, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Fire |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were requested to a location near Newtown Lane by a traffic control officer for a reported incident involving a male and a female in one vehicle outside a nearby church. | Newtown Ln, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Disturbance |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, dispatch reports a persistent noise complaint at a residence near Blue Jay Way in East Hampton. A unit is leaving the Montauk area to respond. | Blue Jay Way, East Hampton, NY 11937 | Disturbance |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers responded to a report of a missing vehicle at a yacht club on Bay Street in Sag Harbor. The caller was later located and the situation was reported as resolved. | Bay St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963 | Stolen Vehicle |
For all crime details - View Safety Report
College Educated Adults
77.6%
Per Capita Income
$134,354
Vacancy Rate
73%
Work From Home Rate
47.2%
Overview
Water Mill is a small, wealthy coastal town in New York with a population of 2,506 and a dominant single-family home market.
The neighborhood is known for its large homes, high education levels, and a very high vacancy rate due to seasonal occupancy.
CoastalWealthyLarge HomesHigh Vacancy
Housing market and real estate character
Water Mill's housing stock is overwhelmingly detached single-family homes, many large in size and well-maintained.
| Large Homes | More large homes than 99.1% of U.S. neighborhoods |
|---|---|
| Detached Single-Family Homes | Dominant housing type, higher than 96.8% of U.S. neighborhoods |
| Housing Type Mix | Almost exclusively detached single-family homes |
What buyers will notice right away
The neighborhood features some of the largest homes in the nation, making a strong visual statement.
Vacancy is very high, typical of resort and second-home areas.
Families & Lifestyle
Water Mill attracts wealthy executives, urban sophisticates, and active retirees seeking a quiet, upscale environment.
The quiet setting and luxury homes appeal to affluent professionals and retirees.
A high share of residents work from home, supporting flexible lifestyles.
Quiet and Peaceful — One of the quietest neighborhoods in America, ideal for those seeking tranquility.
Work From Home Hub — Nearly half of residents work from home, a rate higher than 99.8% of U.S. neighborhoods.
| Executive Lifestyle Rank | Better than 99.3% of NY neighborhoods |
|---|---|
| College Educated Adults | 76.9% |
Demographics
| College Educated Adults | 77.6% |
|---|---|
| Executive, Management, Professional Occupations | 52.0% |
| Child Poverty Rate | 0.0% |
| Income Rank | Top 15% in U.S. |
| English Speakers | 87.2% |
| German/Yiddish Speakers | 2.8% |
| Eastern European Ancestry | 19.9% |
| Russian Ancestry | 4.3% |
Commute
Water Mill residents enjoy short commutes, with a high rate of walking and working from home.
Water Mill's exceptional work-from-home and walk-to-work rates reflect its affluent and flexible lifestyle.
High Work From Home — Nearly half the workforce avoids commuting by working remotely.
Walkable Neighborhood — A significant share of residents walk to work, uncommon in many U.S. neighborhoods.
| Work From Home Rate | 47.2% |
|---|---|
| Walk to Work Rate | 14.7% |
| Drive Alone Rate | 29.3% |
| Train Commute Rate | 6.2% |
Homes for sale near 11962
For-sale listings in this zip code. Open a property in HoodScore to run a safety report.
$89,000,000
8 bd | 10 ba | 9,000 sqft
21 & 407 Fairfield Pond Ln
Sagaponack, NY, 11962
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Water Mill unique?
It has a very high share of large detached homes, a wealthy and educated population, and a high work-from-home rate.
How high is the vacancy rate in Water Mill?
The vacancy rate is 73.0%, typical of resort and second-home communities.
What is the education level in Water Mill?
77.6% of adults have a college degree or higher, well above the national average.