Mastic Beach, NY Neighborhood
Is Old Mastic a Safe Place to Live? Housing, Crime & Buyer Guide
Explore safety, home prices, commute patterns, and neighborhood insights in Mastic Beach, NY - so you can decide with confidence before buying or renting.
Most buyers only see the home. Smart buyers check the neighborhood first.
Crime Summary:
Crime Overview (last 12 months)
Severe310
Medium372
Low483
Other1376
69 Registered Offenders Nearby
Rape24
Child involved28
Assault1
Other24
Crime Details:
Recent reported incidents in the past 12 months (newest first). Up to 10 records.
| Crime date | Crime description | Address | Crime category |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers respond to a report of a white Honda Civic apparently blocking a drive-through near Montauk Highway in Shirley. | Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967 | Traffic |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers responded to a reported disturbance at a fast-food restaurant on Montauk Highway in Shirley involving a white Honda Civic that was apparently blocking the drive-through lane. The situation was later reported as under control. Separate radio traffic also mentioned an open-line hangup call from a location on Lawrence Lane in Ridge. | Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967 | Disturbance |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, radio traffic reports a possible residential structure fire near Baybright Drive in the Mastic Beach area, east of Johns Neck Road. | Baybright Dr, Shirley, NY 11967 | Fire |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a caller reported that people in a gray Mustang allegedly threw powder on the caller’s convertible in a parking lot near Montauk Highway and Velo Avenue in Shirley, with the Mustang last seen heading east on Montauk Highway. | Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967 | Property Damage |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, dispatch reports a possible disturbance at a Sonic Drive-In parking lot near Montauk Highway and Milo Avenue in Shirley, involving a person in a gray Mustang who allegedly threw powder onto a complainant’s convertible coupe. | Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY 11967 | Disturbance |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a welfare check was requested near Old Neck Road between Drew and Twin Pine due to a male in an electric wheelchair with a dead battery who said he was okay. | Twin Pine Ln, Center Moriches, NY 11934 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were dispatched to a reported burglar alarm at a vehicle rental business on East Sunrise Service Road in the Pine Aire area. The alarm reportedly involved motion at the back of the building and sensors at the front door, freight room, and lavatory. | Sunrise Service Rd N, Manorville, NY 11949 | Break-In |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers are responding to a possible burglary alarm at a car rental business on Sunrise Service Road in Brookhaven, with audible alarms and multiple interior motion activations reported. | Sunrise Service Rd N, Brookhaven, NY | Break-In |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, units respond for a possible allergic reaction in Mastic near Carlton Ave off Pershing St involving a young child with swollen eyes and difficulty breathing. | Pershing St & Carlton Ave, Mastic, NY 11950 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, dispatchers report a possible severe allergic reaction involving a minor near Carlton Avenue off Pershing Street in Mastic, with rescue units notified. | Carlton Ave, Mastic, NY 11950 | Medical Emergency |
For all crime details - View Safety Report
Median Home Price
$466,492
Average Rent
$4,191
Vacancy Rate
4.4%
Nearby neighborhoods
Overview
Old Mastic is a suburban coastal neighborhood in Mastic Beach, NY, with a median home price of $466,492 and average rent of $4,191.
The neighborhood is dominated by detached single-family homes, many built between 1940 and 1969, with a low vacancy rate of 4.4%.
Residents have an upper-middle income level, with a low childhood poverty rate of 1.1%.
The area has a strong Italian and Irish ancestry presence, contributing to its cultural character.
CoastalSuburbanUpper-Middle Income
Quick Facts
| Single-Family Homes | Dominant housing type |
|---|
Housing market and real estate character
Old Mastic's housing is primarily medium to small single-family homes, mostly owner occupied, with many built between 1940 and 1969.
| Housing Age | Many homes built between 1940 and 1969 |
|---|---|
| Detached Single-Family Homes | Dominant housing type |
What buyers will notice right away
The neighborhood's coastal location offers waterfront amenities and a nautical atmosphere.
Detached single-family homes dominate the housing stock, indicating a suburban character.
Families & Lifestyle
Old Mastic features an upper-middle income population with diverse occupations and a strong cultural heritage.
Cultural Heritage — High Italian (30.8%) and Irish (28.0%) ancestry contribute to the neighborhood's unique culture.
Occupational Mix — Residents work mainly in executive, manufacturing, sales, and clerical roles.
| Income Level | Upper-middle income |
|---|---|
| Child Poverty Rate | 1.1% |
Demographics
| Executive, Management, Professional Occupations | 32.5% |
|---|---|
| Manufacturing and Laborer Occupations | 30.0% |
| Sales and Service Occupations | 20.5% |
| Clerical, Assistant, Tech Support Occupations | 16.4% |
| English Speakers | 91.0% |
| Other Languages | ["Spanish","Italian","Polish"] |
| Top Ancestries | ["Italian (30.8%)","Irish (28.0%)","German (14.7%)","English (5.8%)","Puerto Rican (4.5%)"] |
Commute
Most residents drive alone to work, with many commuting 30 to 45 minutes one-way.
Old Mastic residents mostly drive alone with moderate commute times typical of suburban areas.
Moderate Commutes — Most residents commute between 30 and 45 minutes.
Carpooling — Carpooling is used by over 11% of residents.
| Commute 30-45 Minutes | 32.1% |
|---|---|
| Drive Alone Rate | 80.8% |
| Carpool Rate | 11.4% |
Homes for sale near 11951
For-sale listings in this zip code. Open a property in HoodScore to run a safety report.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the median home price in Old Mastic?
The median home price is $466,492, more expensive than 36.9% of New York neighborhoods.
What is the dominant housing type?
Detached single-family homes dominate, more than 96.5% of U.S. neighborhoods.