New Suffolk, NY
Is Cutchogue, NY (New Suffolk) a Safe Place to Live? Housing, Crime & Buyer Guide
Explore safety, home prices, commute patterns, and neighborhood insights in Cutchogue, NY - so you can decide with confidence before buying or renting.
Most buyers only see the home. Smart buyers check the neighborhood first.
Crime Summary:
Crime Overview (last 12 months)
Severe128
Medium166
Low277
Other552
29 Registered Offenders Nearby
Rape8
Child involved11
Assault0
Other12
Crime Details:
Recent reported incidents in the past 12 months (newest first). Up to 10 records.
| Crime date | Crime description | Address | Crime category |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, dispatch received an apparent abandoned 911 call with no reported distress from a gas station near Peconic Avenue and Heidi Behr Way. | Old Country Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901 | Suspicious Activity |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers conducted a vehicle records check linked to a traffic stop and then responded to a possible access issue at an apartment on East Main Street, where a superintendent reportedly could not open the location. | E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901 | Traffic |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a female fell and cannot get up at an apartment near East Main Street. | E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers are requested to go to a Riverhead residence for a prior landlord-tenant dispute, where a caller reported that the landlord may have cut off the Wi‑Fi and turned off the power. The officers are asked to speak with the caller’s daughter who is reportedly at the apartment, while the landlord is said to live in the front part of the house. | Ann Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901 | Disturbance |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, fire units are dispatched to a reported bonfire on the beach near Long Neck Boulevard and Fantasy Drive in Flanders, New York. | Longneck Blvd & Fantasy Dr, Flanders, NY 11901 | Fire |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a medical call was dispatched to an address near Middle Road for a 60-year-old man who initially had a possible injury from a fall and was later updated to a possible seizure. | Middle Rd, Riverhead, NY 11901 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers are responding to a reported theft of a package from an apartment at a residential complex on East Main Street. The incident reportedly occurred the previous day. | E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901 | Theft Report |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, radio traffic includes a traffic stop by Crew 11 near Route 24 and Flanders Road involving a New York vehicle plate. In a separate call, fire officials are requested for a residential fire alarm at a home on Foster Crossing near South Main Street and Middle Plains Road. Another later transmission reports a person apparently assaulted by a man near the Bayview Apartments by the town highway depot and train station area, where debris is also noted. | NY-24 & Flanders Rd, Riverside, NY 11901 | Traffic |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, a medical call was dispatched to (number withheld) Peconic Bay Boulevard involving a 76-year-old female. Captain Smith was referenced on the call. | Peconic Bay Blvd, Aquebogue, NY 11931 | Medical Emergency |
| Jul 16, 2026 | As discussed during the dispatch call, officers conducted a welfare check on an uncooperative male near McDermott Avenue and East Main Street. The subject refused police assistance but is reportedly at home with his mother, who has had a stroke, and he acts as her primary caretaker. | McDermott Ave & E Main St, Riverhead, NY 11901 | Medical Emergency |
For all crime details - View Safety Report
Median Home Price
$1,602,072
Average Rent
$4,416
Vacancy Rate
46.2%
Overview
New Suffolk is a rural coastal neighborhood in Cutchogue, NY, known for its quiet, nautical character and predominantly single-family homes.
The median home price is $1,602,072, with an average rent of $4,416. The area has a notably high vacancy rate of 46.2%, often due to seasonal occupancy.
CoastalRuralQuietNautical
Quick Facts
| Rural Population Density | Low |
|---|
Housing market and real estate character
New Suffolk's housing stock is dominated by medium to large single-family homes, mostly owner occupied, with many built between 1970 and 1999.
| Owner Occupied Rate | High |
|---|---|
| Detached Single-Family Homes | Dominant |
| Housing Age | Many built 1970-1999 |
| Seasonal Occupancy | 32.7% |
What buyers will notice right away
Most homes are owner occupied, indicating residential stability.
Significant seasonal occupancy affects vacancy rates, common in vacation areas.
Families & Lifestyle
New Suffolk appeals to retirees, urban sophisticates, executives, and families with school-aged children due to its peaceful environment and diverse housing.
Peaceful and Quiet — One of the quietest neighborhoods in America, ideal for those seeking tranquility.
Nautical Character — Historic and walkable coastal neighborhood with a seaside ambiance.
| Retiree-Friendly Rank in NY | Top 2.3% |
|---|
Demographics
| Executive, Management, Professional Occupations | 49.9% |
|---|---|
| Income Rank in U.S. | Top 15% |
| Child Poverty Rate | 1.9% |
| English Speakers | 86.7% |
| German/Yiddish Speakers | 3.2% |
| Irish Ancestry | 25.6% |
| Ukrainian Ancestry | 3.1% |
Commute
Most residents have short commutes, with many driving alone or taking the train.
New Suffolk offers short commute times and multiple transportation options, supporting a balanced lifestyle.
Short Commutes — Nearly half of residents commute under 15 minutes.
Car and Train Access — Majority drive alone; a notable share uses train transit.
| Commute Under 15 Minutes | 42.9% |
|---|---|
| Drive Alone Rate | 60.7% |
| Train Commute Rate | 5.6% |
Homes for sale near 11931
For-sale listings in this zip code. Open a property in HoodScore to run a safety report.
$449,900
4 bd | 3 ba | 2,646 sqft
11931 SW Crestwood Circle
Port Saint Lucie, FL, 34987
$599,900
4 bd | 3 ba | 3,448 sqft
11931 SW Aventino Drive
Port Saint Lucie, FL, 34987
Frequently Asked Questions
Is New Suffolk a good place for retirees?
Yes, it ranks among the top 2.3% retiree-friendly neighborhoods in New York due to its peacefulness and safety.
What is the housing vacancy rate?
The vacancy rate is 46.2%, largely due to seasonal occupancy common in coastal vacation areas.