Crime & Safety Report for 40 Deforest Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

Review crime and safety information near 40 Deforest Rd, Montauk, NY 11954. HoodScore summarizes nearby reported incidents, registered sex offenders, and neighborhood safety indicators to help buyers and renters perform better location due diligence.

Generated At — 2026-07-25

$17,495,000 | 6 bd | 6 ba | 4,800 sqft

Distance rings: 1 mi and 2 mi from the property.

PropertyIncidentsOffenders

Unlock the full safety report before making a decision about this neighborhood.

Full report contains 3 offenders within 5 miles and 393 crime incidents in the last 12 months.

3 Registered Sex Offenders within 5 miles Near 40 Deforest Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

3 Registered Offenders Nearby
1 Rape
0 Child Involved
0 Assault
2 Other
Photo Name / Age / Tags Arrest / Conviction Address Distance Risk
Offender photo

PETER J BOGETTI

years old

130.60 - Sexual Abuse-2nd Degree

2024-10-03T12:42:28

46 DAVIS DRIVE Montauk, NY, 11954
3.8 Medium

393 Crime & Incidents in the Last 12 Months

393 Crime & Incidents by Severity
54 Severe
68 Medium
65 Low
206 Other
Crime Location (Approx.) Severity Description

Medical Emergency

07/16/2026 08:27 PM

Montauk Hwy, Montauk, NY 11954

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, a possible medical emergency was reported near Montauk Highway involving a (person_name withheld) who indicated someone was unwell before becoming unresponsive on a 911 open line.

Disturbance

07/16/2026 07:14 PM

S Emerson Ave, Montauk, NY 11954

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, officers respond to a reported commercial noise complaint about loud music at a beach business near South Emerson Avenue across from South Edison in Montauk.

Traffic

07/16/2026 07:06 PM

Kirk Park, Montauk, NY 11954

 LOW

As discussed during the dispatch call, officers conduct a traffic-related records check on a vehicle near Kirk Park in Montauk. A New York license plate is run and appears to return valid to an address in East Hampton.

Domestic Dispute

07/16/2026 07:04 PM

Bayberry Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, officers were dispatched to a reported inactive domestic dispute at a residence off Montauk Highway, involving a 60-year-old woman who reported that her husband was verbally abusive and may have been physical in the past. No weapons were reported, and one party was described as Spanish speaking.

Disturbance

07/16/2026 06:23 PM

Farragut Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, officers are dispatched to a reported ongoing noise disturbance coming from a speaker near Farragut Road, with a possible concern about all-day parking in the area.

Similar properties in Montauk

Other for-sale homes in Montauk within about 20% of this listing's price. Open a property for a HoodScore safety preview.

Frequently asked questions

Is 40 Deforest Rd in a low-crime area?

The current report summarizes crime-related incidents within 5 miles during the last 12 months. HoodScore compares these records with relevant benchmarks, but no report can guarantee future safety.

Why are traffic and medical calls shown separately from crime?

Traffic, medical and fire records are public-safety incidents but are not necessarily crimes. HoodScore separates them to avoid overstating the crime count.

How often is this HoodScore report updated?

The report displays its generated date. Update frequency varies by source and is explained in the HoodScore methodology.

How is the HoodScore calculated?

HoodScore combines nearby crime and offender data into a neighborhood safety score. Visit https://www.hoodscore.com/hoodscore-calculator.html to see how the calculation works.