Crime & Safety Report for 5811 SW 1st Pl, Cape Coral, FL 33914

Review crime and safety information near 5811 SW 1st Pl, Cape Coral, FL 33914. HoodScore summarizes nearby reported incidents, registered sex offenders, and neighborhood safety indicators to help buyers and renters perform better location due diligence.

Generated At — 2026-07-26

$1,399,900 | 5 bd | 3 ba | 3,314 sqft

Distance rings: 1 mi and 2 mi from the property.

PropertyIncidentsOffenders

Unlock the full safety report before making a decision about this neighborhood.

Full report contains 97 offenders within 5 miles and 422 crime incidents in the last 12 months.

97 Registered Sex Offenders within 5 miles Near 5811 SW 1st Pl, Cape Coral, FL 33914

97 Registered Offenders Nearby
10 Rape
45 Child Involved
14 Assault
38 Other
Photo Name / Age / Tags Arrest / Conviction Address Distance Risk
Offender photo

TUMMINELLO, JOHN JULIUS

66 years old

Violent

SEX OFFENSE, OTHER STATE (Indecent Assault)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

Sex Offender Fail Comply Registration; F.s. 943.0435(9)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

16930 JUANITA AVE APT A3 FORT MYERS, FL, 33908
4 Medium
Offender photo

NICHOLS, KELLEY RICHARD

62 years old

Child Involved

SEX OFFENSE, OTHER STATE (Lewd or Lascivious Acts w/Child under 14)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

16930 JUANITA AVE APT C2 FORT MYERS, FL, 33908
4 Medium
Offender photo

BARTON, THOMAS MICHAEL

73 years old

Child Involved

252 SE 45TH TER CAPE CORAL, FL, 33904
1.8 Medium
Offender photo

FEHLAU, KARL E

66 years old

Rapist

208 SE 43RD LN CAPE CORAL, FL, 33904
2 Medium
Offender photo

JOHNSON, ROY HAYES

68 years old

Rapist

Violent

4925 EDITH ESPLANADE CAPE CORAL, FL, 33904
2.4 Medium

422 Crime & Incidents in the Last 12 Months

422 Crime & Incidents by Severity
30 Severe
21 Medium
19 Low
352 Other
Crime Location (Approx.) Severity Description

Medical Emergency

07/16/2026 09:28 PM

SW 13th Ave Apt 109, Cape Coral, FL 33914

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, a medical call was reported at an apartment near Southwest 13th Avenue involving an elderly male who appears to have catheter discomfort. Rescue 6 responded to the scene.

Medical Emergency

07/16/2026 09:27 PM

SW 13th Ave, Cape Coral, FL 33914

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, rescue 6 was dispatched to a sick person near Southwest 13th Avenue in Cape Coral.

Medical Emergency

07/16/2026 07:44 PM

SW 27th Terrace, Cape Coral, FL 33914

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, rescue (number withheld) was dispatched for a possible abdominal pain incident near Southwest 27th Terrace.

Medical Emergency

07/16/2026 05:35 PM

SW 47th Terrace, Cape Coral, FL 33914

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, rescue 6 dispatched to a lift-assist medical call near Southwest 47th Terrace involving an elderly male.

Medical Emergency

07/16/2026 03:41 PM

Cape Coral, FL 33914

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, units respond to a medical emergency involving an unconscious patient at a rehabilitation facility near northeast Pine Island Road and nearby major roads in Cape Coral, Florida.

Similar properties in Cape Coral

Other for-sale homes in Cape Coral within about 20% of this listing's price. Open a property for a HoodScore safety preview.

$1,387,000
3 bd | 3 ba | 2,323 sqft
413 SW 46th Terrace Cpe
Cape Coral, FL, 33914
View Safety Report
$1,430,000
4 bd | 4 ba | 2,341 sqft
5870 Shell Cove Dr
Cape Coral, FL, 33914
View Safety Report
$1,325,000
3 bd | 4 ba | 2,433 sqft
2811 SW 34th Terrace Cpe
Cape Coral, FL, 33914
View Safety Report
$1,495,000
4 bd | 3 ba | 2,953 sqft
1434 El Dorado Pkwy W
Cape Coral, FL, 33914
View Safety Report
$1,495,000
3 bd | 4 ba | 2,719 sqft
4804 Pelican BLVD
Cape Coral, FL, 33914
View Safety Report

Frequently asked questions

Is 5811 SW 1st Pl in a low-crime area?

The current report summarizes crime-related incidents within 5 miles during the last 12 months. HoodScore compares these records with relevant benchmarks, but no report can guarantee future safety.

Why are traffic and medical calls shown separately from crime?

Traffic, medical and fire records are public-safety incidents but are not necessarily crimes. HoodScore separates them to avoid overstating the crime count.

How often is this HoodScore report updated?

The report displays its generated date. Update frequency varies by source and is explained in the HoodScore methodology.

How is the HoodScore calculated?

HoodScore combines nearby crime and offender data into a neighborhood safety score. Visit https://www.hoodscore.com/hoodscore-calculator.html to see how the calculation works.