Crime & Safety Report for 5540 DATIL PEPPER Road, St. Augustine, FL 32086

Review crime and safety information near 5540 DATIL PEPPER Road, St. Augustine, FL 32086. HoodScore summarizes nearby reported incidents, registered sex offenders, and neighborhood safety indicators to help buyers and renters perform better location due diligence.

Generated At — 2026-07-26

$540,000 | 3 bd | 2 ba | 1,536 sqft

Distance rings: 1 mi and 2 mi from the property.

PropertyIncidentsOffenders

Unlock the full safety report before making a decision about this neighborhood.

Full report contains 6 offenders within 5 miles and 24 crime incidents in the last 12 months.

6 Registered Sex Offenders within 5 miles Near 5540 DATIL PEPPER Road, St. Augustine, FL 32086

6 Registered Offenders Nearby
0 Rape
4 Child Involved
1 Assault
2 Other
Photo Name / Age / Tags Arrest / Conviction Address Distance Risk
Offender photo

EDINGER, ROBERT T

61 years old

SEX BAT/INJ NOT LIKELY; F.S. 794.011(5) (2 COUNTS - PRINCIPAL)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

309 SAINT AUGUSTINE SOUTH DR SAINT AUGUSTINE, FL, 32086
4.5 Medium
Offender photo

LEDUC, ERIC HENRY

47 years old

Child Involved

Violent

SEX OFFENSE, OTHER STATE (INDECENT ASSAULT & BATTERY ON A CHILD UNDER 14. MA STATUTE 265: SECTION 13B)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

3960 A1A S UNIT 512 SAINT AUGUSTINE BEACH, FL, 32080
4.1 Medium
Offender photo

ADOMAITIS, JEREMY JAMES

45 years old

Lewd or lascivious molestation victim 12-15 years old offender 18 or older; F.S. 800.04(5)(c)(2)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

Lewd or lascivious molestation victim 12-15 years old offender 18 or older; F.S. 800.04(5)(c)(2)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

4105 VERMONT BLVD ELKTON, FL, 32033
4.9 Medium
Offender photo

COHN, JEFFREY ROBERT

37 years old

Child Involved

Produce, Direct, Promote Sexual Perform. by Child; F.S. 827.071(3)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

POSS OF PHOTO/PICTURE SHOWING SEXUAL PERFORMANCE BY A CHILD; F.S. 827.071(5)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

399 W NEW ENGLAND DR ELKTON, FL, 32033
4.8 Medium
Offender photo

MCNINNEY, PAUL LEE

72 years old

Child Involved

SEX OFFENSE, OTHER STATE (Possession Of Child Pornography)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

POSS OF PHOTO/PICTURE SHOWING SEXUAL PERFORMANCE BY A CHILD; F.S. 827.071(5)

2024-09-02T17:06:34

422 W NEW ENGLAND DR ELKTON, FL, 32033
4.8 Medium

24 Crime & Incidents in the Last 12 Months

24 Crime & Incidents by Severity
3 Severe
2 Medium
19 Other
Crime Location (Approx.) Severity Description

Fire

07/04/2026 10:23 AM

Legends Ln, Elkton, FL 32033

 MEDIUM

As discussed during the dispatch call, fire units were sent to a reported residential fire alarm near Legends Lane. Crews arrived at a single-story home with nothing visible and the situation was reported under control after investigation. Other units were also dispatched to a separate medical assist call near Woodfield Lane.

Medical Emergency

07/04/2026 07:07 AM

Verano Point Way, Elkton, FL 32033

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, engine 11 dispatched to help a citizen with lifting near Verano Point Way in zone 11.

Medical Emergency

07/04/2026 04:40 AM

Las Brisas Pl, Elkton, FL 32033

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, medical units respond to a possible medical emergency near Las Brisas Place in Elkton.

Fire

07/02/2026 12:15 PM

Golf Ridge Dr, Elkton, FL 32033

 MEDIUM

As discussed during the dispatch call, emergency crews are responding to a possible hazardous materials spill or leak near Golf Ridge Drive in Elkton, Florida. Radio traffic for the incident was moved to a different channel for coordination.

Medical Emergency

07/02/2026 04:50 AM

Deerpark Blvd, Elkton, FL 32033

 Unknown

As discussed during the dispatch call, medical units responded to a medical assist call at the Magnolia Building near Deerpark Boulevard. The incident involved unit (number withheld).

Nearby Schools

Schools within 2 miles of this property, nearest first.

SchoolDistance
W. DOUGLAS HARTLEY ELEMENTARY0.7 mi
GAMBLE ROGERS MIDDLE SCHOOL1.2 mi

Similar properties in Saint Augustine

Other for-sale homes in Saint Augustine within about 20% of this listing's price. Open a property for a HoodScore safety preview.

$540,000
4 bd | 4 ba | 2,499 sqft
123 Hickory Ridge Rd
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$539,000
2 bd | 2 ba | 1,844 sqft
320 Ravenswood Dr
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$535,000
3 bd | 2 ba | 1,708 sqft
166 Martin Luther King Ave
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$535,000
3 bd | 2 ba | 1,003 sqft
136 Washington St
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$547,000
3 bd | 2 ba | 1,420 sqft
3051 GREEN ACRES Road
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$524,900
4 bd | 2 ba | 1,551 sqft
112 Martin Luther King Ave
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$559,000
2 bd | 2 ba | 1,600 sqft
3219 HARBOR Drive
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$575,000
4 bd | 3 ba | 1,442 sqft
18 ESTEY Street
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report
$575,000
3 bd | 2 ba | 1,250 sqft
127 Lincoln St
Saint Augustine, FL, 32084
View Safety Report

Frequently asked questions

Is 5540 DATIL PEPPER Road in a low-crime area?

The current report summarizes crime-related incidents within 5 miles during the last 12 months. HoodScore compares these records with relevant benchmarks, but no report can guarantee future safety.

Why are traffic and medical calls shown separately from crime?

Traffic, medical and fire records are public-safety incidents but are not necessarily crimes. HoodScore separates them to avoid overstating the crime count.

How often is this HoodScore report updated?

The report displays its generated date. Update frequency varies by source and is explained in the HoodScore methodology.

How is the HoodScore calculated?

HoodScore combines nearby crime and offender data into a neighborhood safety score. Visit https://www.hoodscore.com/hoodscore-calculator.html to see how the calculation works.